PHP hook, building hooks in your application
Introduction
One of the real challenges in building any type of framework, core or application is making it possible for the developers to hook into the business logic at specific points. Since PHP is not event based, nor it works with interrupts you have to come up an alternative.
The test case
Lets assume we are the main developers of a webshop framework. Programmers can use our framework to build complete webshops. Programmers can manage the orders that are placed on the webshop with the order class. The order class is part of our framework and we don’t want it to be extended by any programmer. However we don’t want to limit to programmers in their possibilities to hook into the orders process.
For example programmers should be able to send an email to the webshopowner if an order changes from one specific delivery status to another. This functionality is not part of the default behavior in our framework and is custom for the progammers webshop implementation.
Like said before, PHP doesn’t provide interrupts or real events so we need to come up with another way to implement hooks into our application. Lets take a look at the observer pattern.
Implementing the Observer pattern
The observer pattern is a design-pattern that describes a way for objects to be notified to specific state-changes in objects of the application.
For the first implementation we can use SPL. The SPL provides in two simple objects:
SPLSubject
- attach (new observer to attach)
- detach (existing observer to detach)
- notify (notify all observers)
SPLObserver
- update (Called from the subject (i.e. when it’s value has changed).
iOrderRef = $iOrderRef;
// Get order information from the database or an other resources
$this->iStatus = Order::STATUS_SHIPPED;
}
/**
* Attach an observer
*
* @param SplObserver $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function attach(SplObserver $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer is already attached');
}
$this->aObservers[$sHash] = $oObserver;
}
/**
* Detach observer
*
* @param SplObserver $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function detach(SplObserver $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (!isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer not attached');
}
unset($this->aObservers[$sHash]);
}
/**
* Notify the attached observers
*
* @param string $sEvent, name of the event
* @param mixed $mData, optional data that is not directly available for the observers
* @return void
*/
public function notify()
{
foreach ($this->aObservers as $oObserver) {
try {
$oObserver->update($this);
} catch(Exception $e) {
}
}
}
/**
* Add an order
*
* @param array $aOrder
* @return void
*/
public function delete()
{
$this->notify();
}
/**
* Return the order reference number
*
* @return int
*/
public function getRef()
{
return $this->iOrderRef;
}
/**
* Return the current order status
*
* @return int
*/
public function getStatus()
{
return $this->iStatus;
}
/**
* Update the order status
*/
public function updateStatus($iStatus)
{
$this->notify();
// ...
$this->iStatus = $iStatus;
// ...
$this->notify();
}
}
/**
* Order status handler, observer that sends an email to secretary
* if the status of an order changes from shipped to delivered, so the
* secratary can make a phone call to our customer to ask for his opinion about the service
*
* @package Shop
*/
class OrderStatusHandler implements SplObserver
{
/**
* Previous orderstatus
* @var int
*/
protected $iPreviousOrderStatus;
/**
* Current orderstatus
* @var int
*/
protected $iCurrentOrderStatus;
/**
* Update, called by the observable object order
*
* @param Observable_Interface $oSubject
* @param string $sEvent
* @param mixed $mData
* @return void
*/
public function update(SplSubject $oSubject)
{
if(!$oSubject instanceof Order) {
return;
}
if(is_null($this->iPreviousOrderStatus)) {
$this->iPreviousOrderStatus = $oSubject->getStatus();
} else {
$this->iCurrentOrderStatus = $oSubject->getStatus();
if($this->iPreviousOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_SHIPPED && $this->iCurrentOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_DELIVERED) {
$sSubject = sprintf('Order number %d is shipped', $oSubject->getRef());
//mail('secratary@example.com', 'Order number %d is shipped', 'Text');
echo 'Mail sended to the secratary to help her remember to call our customer for a survey.';
}
}
}
}
$oOrder = new Order(26012011);
$oOrder->attach(new OrderStatusHandler());
$oOrder->updateStatus(Order::STATUS_DELIVERED);
$oOrder->delete();
?>
There are several problems with the implementation above. To most important disadvantage is that we have only one update method in our observer. In this update method we don’t know when and why we are getting notified, just that something happened. We should keep track of everything that happens in the subject. (Or use debug_backtrace… just joking, don’t even think about using it that way ever!).
Taking it a step further, events
Lets take a look at the next example, we will extend the Observer implementation with some an additional parameter for the eventname that occured.
Finishing up, optional data
iOrderRef = $iOrderRef;
// Get order information from the database or something else...
$this->iStatus = Order::STATUS_SHIPPED;
}
/**
* Attach an observer
*
* @param Observer_Interface $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function attachObserver(Observer_Interface $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer is already attached');
}
$this->aObservers[$sHash] = $oObserver;
}
/**
* Detach observer
*
* @param Observer_Interface $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function detachObserver(Observer_Interface $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (!isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer not attached');
}
unset($this->aObservers[$sHash]);
}
/**
* Notify the attached observers
*
* @param string $sEvent, name of the event
* @param mixed $mData, optional data that is not directly available for the observers
* @return void
*/
public function notifyObserver($sEvent, $mData=null)
{
foreach ($this->aObservers as $oObserver) {
try {
$oObserver->update($this, $sEvent, $mData);
} catch(Exception $e) {
}
}
}
/**
* Add an order
*
* @param array $aOrder
* @return void
*/
public function add($aOrder = array())
{
$this->notifyObserver('onAdd');
}
/**
* Return the order reference number
*
* @return int
*/
public function getRef()
{
return $this->iOrderRef;
}
/**
* Return the current order status
*
* @return int
*/
public function getStatus()
{
return $this->iStatus;
}
/**
* Update the order status
*/
public function updateStatus($iStatus)
{
$this->notifyObserver('onBeforeUpdateStatus');
// ...
$this->iStatus = $iStatus;
// ...
$this->notifyObserver('onAfterUpdateStatus');
}
}
/**
* Order status handler, observer that sends an email to secretary
* if the status of an order changes from shipped to delivered, so the
* secratary can make a phone call to our customer to ask for his opinion about the service
*
* @package Shop
*/
class OrderStatusHandler implements Observer_Interface
{
protected $iPreviousOrderStatus;
protected $iCurrentOrderStatus;
/**
* Update, called by the observable object order
*
* @param Observable_Interface $oObservable
* @param string $sEvent
* @param mixed $mData
* @return void
*/
public function update(Observable_Interface $oObservable, $sEvent, $mData=null)
{
if(!$oObservable instanceof Order) {
return;
}
switch($sEvent) {
case 'onBeforeUpdateStatus':
$this->iPreviousOrderStatus = $oObservable->getStatus();
return;
case 'onAfterUpdateStatus':
$this->iCurrentOrderStatus = $oObservable->getStatus();
if($this->iPreviousOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_SHIPPED && $this->iCurrentOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_DELIVERED) {
$sSubject = sprintf('Order number %d is shipped', $oObservable->getRef());
//mail('secratary@example.com', 'Order number %d is shipped', 'Text');
echo 'Mail sended to the secratary to help her remember to call our customer for a survey.';
}
}
}
}
$oOrder = new Order(26012011);
$oOrder->attachObserver(new OrderStatusHandler());
$oOrder->updateStatus(Order::STATUS_DELIVERED);
$oOrder->add();
?>
Now we are able to take action on different events that occur.
Disadvantages
Although this implementation works quite well there are some drawbacks. One of those drawbacks is that we need to dispatch an event in our framework, if we don’t programmers can’t hook into our application. Triggering events everywhere give us a small performance penalty however I do think this way of working gives the programmers a nice way to hook into your application on those spots that you want them to hook in.
Just for the record
Notice that this code is just an example and can still use some improvements, for example: each observer is initialized even it will maybe never be notified, therefore I suggest to make use of lazy in some cases for loading the objects. There are other systems to hook into an application, more to follow!
https://xmas-drop-play.top
ThomasHab
19 Aug 25 at 1:51 pm
купить аттестат за 11 класс казахстан [url=www.arus-diplom24.ru/]купить аттестат за 11 класс казахстан[/url] .
Diplomi_rnKn
19 Aug 25 at 1:58 pm
Hello! I simply want to offer you a big
thumbs up for the great information you’ve got right
here on this post. I will be returning to your site for more soon.
macauslot88 login
19 Aug 25 at 2:01 pm
Этот текст призван помочь читателю расширить кругозор и получить практические знания. Мы используем простой язык, наглядные примеры и структурированное изложение, чтобы сделать обучение максимально эффективным и увлекательным.
Подробная информация доступна по запросу – https://www.sendmecashtoday.ca/2025/03/24/installment-loans-in-halifax
Cliftonjam
19 Aug 25 at 2:07 pm
https://say.la/read-blog/126254
JustinTup
19 Aug 25 at 2:08 pm
Публикация приглашает вас исследовать неизведанное — от древних тайн до современных достижений науки. Вы узнаете, как случайные находки превращались в революции, а смелые мысли — в новые эры человеческого прогресса.
Почему это важно? – https://passable.art/exhibitions/ye-olde-curiosity-shop
DonaldRop
19 Aug 25 at 2:14 pm
https://odysee.com/@elfidotensui
Michaelmot
19 Aug 25 at 2:15 pm
In recent years, more and more people have become interested in binary options trading. Among them, “theoption” is known as a platform that is easy to use even for beginners. With its simple and intuitive user interface, even first-time traders can use it with confidence.
Theoption fully supports the Japanese language and provides reliable customer support. Moreover, because the minimum trade amount is low, it is ideal for those who want to start with a small investment.
For more detailed information, please check the following website:
https://yomimonoweb.jp/
Anthonybex
19 Aug 25 at 2:16 pm
В этой статье представлен занимательный и актуальный контент, который заставит вас задуматься. Мы обсуждаем насущные вопросы и проблемы, а также освещаем истории, которые вдохновляют на действия и изменения. Узнайте, что стоит за событиями нашего времени!
Почему это важно? – https://cleverblogger.in/2024/10/31/guide-to-buying-real-uk-instagram-followers
DonaldRop
19 Aug 25 at 2:16 pm
Близкий человек в запое? Не ждите ухудшения. Обратитесь в клинику — здесь проведут профессиональный вывод из запоя с последующим восстановлением организма.
Узнать больше – [url=https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-v-sankt-peterburge17.ru/]нарколог вывод из запоя в санкт-петербурге[/url]
Andrewleaws
19 Aug 25 at 2:17 pm
Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon every day.
It will always be interesting to read through articles from other writers
and use something from their sites.
casino online deutschland
19 Aug 25 at 2:18 pm
Hi, this weekend is nice in favor of me, because this time i am reading this enormous educational piece of writing here at my house.
https://itsybitsyfirstgradeteacher.com/sklo-fary-khrumtyt-chy-mozhna-yizdyty.html
Dichaelwaw
19 Aug 25 at 2:18 pm
Когда организм на пределе, важна срочная помощь в Санкт-Петербурге — это команда опытных наркологов, которые помогут быстро и мягко выйти из запоя без вреда для здоровья.
Получить больше информации – [url=https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-v-sankt-peterburge15.ru/]вывод из запоя клиника в санкт-петербурге[/url]
Josephkeync
19 Aug 25 at 2:19 pm
I go to see everyday a few web sites and blogs to read articles
or reviews, except this webpage gives quality based content.
Centerton roofing company
19 Aug 25 at 2:20 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://tor-kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.com]kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken7jmgt7yhhe2c4iyilthnhcugfylcztsdhh7otrr6jgdw667pqd0.com]kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad onion[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken6gf6o4rxewycqwjgfchzgxyfeoj5xafqbfm4vgvyaig2vmxvyd onion
https://kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo3ad.com
Thomasslete
19 Aug 25 at 2:22 pm
This post is truly a nice one it assists new net
users, who are wishing in favor of blogging.
kra36
19 Aug 25 at 2:22 pm
Great info. Lucky me I recently found your site by accident
(stumbleupon). I’ve saved as a favorite for later!
시알리스 구매 사이트
19 Aug 25 at 2:24 pm
купить аттестат за 11 класс алматы [url=https://www.arus-diplom24.ru]купить аттестат за 11 класс алматы[/url] .
Diplomi_lrKn
19 Aug 25 at 2:24 pm
Публикация приглашает вас исследовать неизведанное — от древних тайн до современных достижений науки. Вы узнаете, как случайные находки превращались в революции, а смелые мысли — в новые эры человеческого прогресса.
Изучить аспект более тщательно – https://melle-art.de/foto-19-11-17-02-46-43
Cliftonjam
19 Aug 25 at 2:24 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo3ad.com]kraken3yvbvzmhytnrnuhsy772i6dfobofu652e27f5hx6y5cpj7rgyd onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7.com]kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad onion[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken4qzqnoi7ogpzpzwrxk7mw53n5i56loydwiyonu4owxsh4g67yd
https://tor-kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.com
Thomasslete
19 Aug 25 at 2:25 pm
https://rant.li/gaagegeghki/kupit-kanabis-marikhuanu-gashish-zanzibar
JustinTup
19 Aug 25 at 2:28 pm
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – sildenafil 200mg
RichardTit
19 Aug 25 at 2:29 pm
новости легкой атлетики [url=https://novosti-sporta-12.ru/]novosti-sporta-12.ru[/url] .
novosti sporta_thsl
19 Aug 25 at 2:29 pm
https://sildenapeak.shop/# how do i get viagra
Danielchumn
19 Aug 25 at 2:34 pm
Folks, bｅtter stay vigilant hor, leading primary graduates commonly join Raffles ⲟr Hwa Chong, unlocking routes to grants
overseas.
Оh dear, elite primaries provide tale-telling, developing narrative f᧐r author careers.
Oi oi,Singapore folks, math іs probably tһe extremely crucial primary
topic, promoting imagination tһrough challenge-tackling fοr groundbreaking
jobs.
Parents, kiasu mode ߋn lah, robust primary
math leads іn superior sciesnce grasp and construction dreams.
Іn addition from establishment resources, emphasize ѡith
arithmetic tօ ɑvoid common mistakes ⅼike inattentive blunders аt exams.
Oһ, math serves as thе foundation pillar ᧐f primary education, helping kids ѡith spatial thinking fοr design routes.
Aiyah, primary mathematics teaches practical սses such as
budgeting, thеrefore make sure your youngster masters this properly ƅeginning young age.
Cantonment Primary School promotes ɑn encouraging environment
where yoᥙng students prosper academically.
Dedicated personnel аnd varied activities assist build ѕelf-confidence and lifelong skills.
Edgefield Primary School supplies а helpful neighborhood fοr growth.
Ꮃith varied programs, it nurtures talents effectively.
Ιt’s a solid option fօr holistic development.
Ꮋere is my рage – St. Anthony’s Canossian Secondary School
St. Anthony's Canossian Secondary School
19 Aug 25 at 2:36 pm
Good post! We will be linking to this great post on our site.
Keep up the great writing.
megaweb6.at
19 Aug 25 at 2:37 pm
http://kamameds.com/# KamaMeds
Danielchumn
19 Aug 25 at 2:39 pm
новости легкой атлетики [url=http://novosti-sporta-12.ru]http://novosti-sporta-12.ru[/url] .
novosti sporta_posl
19 Aug 25 at 2:40 pm
Wow, fantastic blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is magnificent,
as well as the content!
86bet.com
19 Aug 25 at 2:43 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5n7instad.com]kraken4qzqnoi7ogpzpzwrxk7mw53n5i56loydwiyonu4owxsh4g67yd.onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad.shop]kraken3yvbvzmhytnrnuhsy772i6dfobofu652e27f5hx6y5cpj7rgyd[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.onion
https://kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad0.com
Jamesbow
19 Aug 25 at 2:43 pm
https://linkin.bio/mihulaberen
JustinTup
19 Aug 25 at 2:48 pm
купить аттестаты за 11 вечерней школе в партизанске [url=www.arus-diplom24.ru/]купить аттестаты за 11 вечерней школе в партизанске[/url] .
Diplomi_agKn
19 Aug 25 at 2:49 pm
luxury1288
luxury1288
19 Aug 25 at 2:55 pm
What’s up to all, the contents present at this site are genuinely
remarkable for people knowledge, well, keep up the good work fellows.
danske spil casino
19 Aug 25 at 2:59 pm
https://rant.li/ofubqeodu/nesebr-kupit-kokain-mefedron-marikhuanu
Michaelmot
19 Aug 25 at 2:59 pm
Tadalify: online cialis prescription – Tadalify
ElijahKic
19 Aug 25 at 3:01 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7.com]kraken4qzqnoi7ogpzpzwrxk7mw53n5i56loydwiyonu4owxsh4g67yd.onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5.com]kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad onion[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken3yvbvzmhytnrnuhsy772i6dfobofu652e27f5hx6y5cpj7rgyd onion
https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4a337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.com
ThomasNib
19 Aug 25 at 3:02 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa7cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.com]kraken3yvbvzmhytnrnuhsy772i6dfobofu652e27f5hx6y5cpj7rgyd onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken4qzqnoi7ogpzpzwrxk7mw53n5i56loydwiyonu4owxsh4g67yd0.com]kraken6gf6o4rxewycqwjgfchzgxyfeoj5xafqbfm4vgvyaig2vmxvyd[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken6gf6o4rxewycqwjgfchzgxyfeoj5xafqbfm4vgvyaig2vmxvyd onion
https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa7cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.com
ThomasNib
19 Aug 25 at 3:05 pm
новости легкой атлетики [url=novosti-sporta-12.ru]novosti-sporta-12.ru[/url] .
novosti sporta_mcsl
19 Aug 25 at 3:06 pm
https://pxlmo.com/malisehetag
JustinTup
19 Aug 25 at 3:09 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7inst.com]kraken6gf6o4rxewycqwjgfchzgxyfeoj5xafqbfm4vgvyaig2vmxvyd.onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4a337cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad-onion.com]kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad.onion[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken7jmgt7yhhe2c4iyilthnhcugfylcztsdhh7otrr6jgdw667pqd.onion
https://kraken7jmgt7yhhe2c4iyilthnhcugfylcztsdhh7otrr6jgdw667pqd0.com
ScottWorse
19 Aug 25 at 3:09 pm
He has had more cordial, more productive, meetings with US President Donald Trump since that now-notorious encounter on February 28.
[url=https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa7cpzfrhdlfldhve5nf7njhumwr7instad.com]kraken4qzqnoi7ogpzpzwrxk7mw53n5i56loydwiyonu4owxsh4g67yd onion[/url]
But for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, today’s meeting at the White House will surely trigger awkward memories of that very public clash with the US President almost six months ago. Navigating the treacherous waters in which he finds himself today will be no easier.
[url=https://kraken4qzqnoi7ogpzpzwrxk7mw53n5i56loydwiyonu4owxsh4g67ydonion.info]kraken5af44k24fwzohe6fvqfgxfsee4lgydb3ayzkfhlzqhuwlo33ad[/url]
Increasingly, it appears likely he will be told to give up land in exchange for some sort of security guarantees.
The land side of that “deal” will be obvious. It can be drawn on a map. Crimea: gone, says Trump. Donetsk: give all of it up, says Putin, apparently with Trump’s blessing.
But the security guarantees? That’s where far more challenging ideas, like credibility, come into play. Could Zelensky rely on the US to deliver on some NATO Article 5-type promise, to defend Ukraine if Russia breaches any peace agreement?
Putin himself might even see an opportunity to further weaken the West, by testing any such guarantees, confident they are a bluff he could call. But all that would be for the future.
For now, it looks like Zelensky will have to weigh up whether he could bring his country with him if he were to cede territory to Russia – some of it still in Ukrainian hands – or whether he and his people could bear the costs of potentially defying Trump a Nobel Peace Prize, and say no.
If he chose the latter, would the US President immediately end all remaining American support for Ukraine, in terms of military aid and intelligence sharing, for instance?
If that happened, to what extent could Zelensky’s European allies really step in and fill in the gaps left by any full US retreat?
It is an almost impossibly hard choice before him.
kraken6gf6o4rxewycqwjgfchzgxyfeoj5xafqbfm4vgvyaig2vmxvyd.onion
https://kraken2trfqodidvlh4aa337cpzfrhdlfldhve5n7instad.com
ScottWorse
19 Aug 25 at 3:12 pm
купить аттестат об окончании 11 классов в ижевске [url=http://arus-diplom24.ru/]купить аттестат об окончании 11 классов в ижевске[/url] .
Diplomi_wmKn
19 Aug 25 at 3:12 pm
I visited several websites however the audio feature for audio songs existing at this web page is really superb.
dt68.uk.com
19 Aug 25 at 3:17 pm
новости футбола [url=www.novosti-sporta-12.ru]новости футбола[/url] .
novosti sporta_gtsl
19 Aug 25 at 3:17 pm
купить аттестат за 11 класс lr 63 [url=https://arus-diplom24.ru/]купить аттестат за 11 класс lr 63[/url] .
Diplomi_dmKn
19 Aug 25 at 3:18 pm
A person necessarily lend a hand to make seriously
posts I’d state. This is the first time I frequented your web page
and up to now? I amazed with the research you made to make this actual put up incredible.
Magnificent task!
kontol besar
19 Aug 25 at 3:18 pm
Hi there, I want to subscribe for this weblog
to get latest updates, therefore where can i do it please help out.
we999
19 Aug 25 at 3:18 pm
Посетите сайт https://kedu.ru/ и вы найдете учебные программы, курсы, семинары и вебинары от лучших учебных заведений и частных преподавателей в России с ценами, рейтингами и отзывами. Также вы можете сравнить ВУЗы, колледжи, учебные центры, репетиторов. KEDU – самый большой каталог образования.
tehepelcam
19 Aug 25 at 3:19 pm
Online sources for Kamagra in the United States [url=https://kamameds.shop/#]ED treatment without doctor visits[/url] Online sources for Kamagra in the United States
RobertCat
19 Aug 25 at 3:20 pm