PHP hook, building hooks in your application
Introduction
One of the real challenges in building any type of framework, core or application is making it possible for the developers to hook into the business logic at specific points. Since PHP is not event based, nor it works with interrupts you have to come up an alternative.
The test case
Lets assume we are the main developers of a webshop framework. Programmers can use our framework to build complete webshops. Programmers can manage the orders that are placed on the webshop with the order class. The order class is part of our framework and we don’t want it to be extended by any programmer. However we don’t want to limit to programmers in their possibilities to hook into the orders process.
For example programmers should be able to send an email to the webshopowner if an order changes from one specific delivery status to another. This functionality is not part of the default behavior in our framework and is custom for the progammers webshop implementation.
Like said before, PHP doesn’t provide interrupts or real events so we need to come up with another way to implement hooks into our application. Lets take a look at the observer pattern.
Implementing the Observer pattern
The observer pattern is a design-pattern that describes a way for objects to be notified to specific state-changes in objects of the application.
For the first implementation we can use SPL. The SPL provides in two simple objects:
SPLSubject
- attach (new observer to attach)
- detach (existing observer to detach)
- notify (notify all observers)
SPLObserver
- update (Called from the subject (i.e. when it’s value has changed).
iOrderRef = $iOrderRef;
// Get order information from the database or an other resources
$this->iStatus = Order::STATUS_SHIPPED;
}
/**
* Attach an observer
*
* @param SplObserver $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function attach(SplObserver $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer is already attached');
}
$this->aObservers[$sHash] = $oObserver;
}
/**
* Detach observer
*
* @param SplObserver $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function detach(SplObserver $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (!isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer not attached');
}
unset($this->aObservers[$sHash]);
}
/**
* Notify the attached observers
*
* @param string $sEvent, name of the event
* @param mixed $mData, optional data that is not directly available for the observers
* @return void
*/
public function notify()
{
foreach ($this->aObservers as $oObserver) {
try {
$oObserver->update($this);
} catch(Exception $e) {
}
}
}
/**
* Add an order
*
* @param array $aOrder
* @return void
*/
public function delete()
{
$this->notify();
}
/**
* Return the order reference number
*
* @return int
*/
public function getRef()
{
return $this->iOrderRef;
}
/**
* Return the current order status
*
* @return int
*/
public function getStatus()
{
return $this->iStatus;
}
/**
* Update the order status
*/
public function updateStatus($iStatus)
{
$this->notify();
// ...
$this->iStatus = $iStatus;
// ...
$this->notify();
}
}
/**
* Order status handler, observer that sends an email to secretary
* if the status of an order changes from shipped to delivered, so the
* secratary can make a phone call to our customer to ask for his opinion about the service
*
* @package Shop
*/
class OrderStatusHandler implements SplObserver
{
/**
* Previous orderstatus
* @var int
*/
protected $iPreviousOrderStatus;
/**
* Current orderstatus
* @var int
*/
protected $iCurrentOrderStatus;
/**
* Update, called by the observable object order
*
* @param Observable_Interface $oSubject
* @param string $sEvent
* @param mixed $mData
* @return void
*/
public function update(SplSubject $oSubject)
{
if(!$oSubject instanceof Order) {
return;
}
if(is_null($this->iPreviousOrderStatus)) {
$this->iPreviousOrderStatus = $oSubject->getStatus();
} else {
$this->iCurrentOrderStatus = $oSubject->getStatus();
if($this->iPreviousOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_SHIPPED && $this->iCurrentOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_DELIVERED) {
$sSubject = sprintf('Order number %d is shipped', $oSubject->getRef());
//mail('secratary@example.com', 'Order number %d is shipped', 'Text');
echo 'Mail sended to the secratary to help her remember to call our customer for a survey.';
}
}
}
}
$oOrder = new Order(26012011);
$oOrder->attach(new OrderStatusHandler());
$oOrder->updateStatus(Order::STATUS_DELIVERED);
$oOrder->delete();
?>
There are several problems with the implementation above. To most important disadvantage is that we have only one update method in our observer. In this update method we don’t know when and why we are getting notified, just that something happened. We should keep track of everything that happens in the subject. (Or use debug_backtrace… just joking, don’t even think about using it that way ever!).
Taking it a step further, events
Lets take a look at the next example, we will extend the Observer implementation with some an additional parameter for the eventname that occured.
Finishing up, optional data
iOrderRef = $iOrderRef;
// Get order information from the database or something else...
$this->iStatus = Order::STATUS_SHIPPED;
}
/**
* Attach an observer
*
* @param Observer_Interface $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function attachObserver(Observer_Interface $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer is already attached');
}
$this->aObservers[$sHash] = $oObserver;
}
/**
* Detach observer
*
* @param Observer_Interface $oObserver
* @return void
*/
public function detachObserver(Observer_Interface $oObserver)
{
$sHash = spl_object_hash($oObserver);
if (!isset($this->aObservers[$sHash])) {
throw new Exception('Observer not attached');
}
unset($this->aObservers[$sHash]);
}
/**
* Notify the attached observers
*
* @param string $sEvent, name of the event
* @param mixed $mData, optional data that is not directly available for the observers
* @return void
*/
public function notifyObserver($sEvent, $mData=null)
{
foreach ($this->aObservers as $oObserver) {
try {
$oObserver->update($this, $sEvent, $mData);
} catch(Exception $e) {
}
}
}
/**
* Add an order
*
* @param array $aOrder
* @return void
*/
public function add($aOrder = array())
{
$this->notifyObserver('onAdd');
}
/**
* Return the order reference number
*
* @return int
*/
public function getRef()
{
return $this->iOrderRef;
}
/**
* Return the current order status
*
* @return int
*/
public function getStatus()
{
return $this->iStatus;
}
/**
* Update the order status
*/
public function updateStatus($iStatus)
{
$this->notifyObserver('onBeforeUpdateStatus');
// ...
$this->iStatus = $iStatus;
// ...
$this->notifyObserver('onAfterUpdateStatus');
}
}
/**
* Order status handler, observer that sends an email to secretary
* if the status of an order changes from shipped to delivered, so the
* secratary can make a phone call to our customer to ask for his opinion about the service
*
* @package Shop
*/
class OrderStatusHandler implements Observer_Interface
{
protected $iPreviousOrderStatus;
protected $iCurrentOrderStatus;
/**
* Update, called by the observable object order
*
* @param Observable_Interface $oObservable
* @param string $sEvent
* @param mixed $mData
* @return void
*/
public function update(Observable_Interface $oObservable, $sEvent, $mData=null)
{
if(!$oObservable instanceof Order) {
return;
}
switch($sEvent) {
case 'onBeforeUpdateStatus':
$this->iPreviousOrderStatus = $oObservable->getStatus();
return;
case 'onAfterUpdateStatus':
$this->iCurrentOrderStatus = $oObservable->getStatus();
if($this->iPreviousOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_SHIPPED && $this->iCurrentOrderStatus === Order::STATUS_DELIVERED) {
$sSubject = sprintf('Order number %d is shipped', $oObservable->getRef());
//mail('secratary@example.com', 'Order number %d is shipped', 'Text');
echo 'Mail sended to the secratary to help her remember to call our customer for a survey.';
}
}
}
}
$oOrder = new Order(26012011);
$oOrder->attachObserver(new OrderStatusHandler());
$oOrder->updateStatus(Order::STATUS_DELIVERED);
$oOrder->add();
?>
Now we are able to take action on different events that occur.
Disadvantages
Although this implementation works quite well there are some drawbacks. One of those drawbacks is that we need to dispatch an event in our framework, if we don’t programmers can’t hook into our application. Triggering events everywhere give us a small performance penalty however I do think this way of working gives the programmers a nice way to hook into your application on those spots that you want them to hook in.
Just for the record
Notice that this code is just an example and can still use some improvements, for example: each observer is initialized even it will maybe never be notified, therefore I suggest to make use of lazy in some cases for loading the objects. There are other systems to hook into an application, more to follow!
купить диплом лаборанта [url=http://rudik-diplom6.ru/]купить диплом лаборанта[/url] .
Diplomi_nmKr
20 Oct 25 at 8:39 am
It’s really a cool and helpful piece of information. I am happy that
you simply shared this helpful info with us. Please
keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.
penalty game online
20 Oct 25 at 8:39 am
купить диплом в октябрьском [url=http://rudik-diplom11.ru]купить диплом в октябрьском[/url] .
Diplomi_viMi
20 Oct 25 at 8:39 am
Время зачисления средств на персональный счет пользователя зависит от выбранного
платежного сервиса, но, как правило, не превышает
трех дней.
покердом зеркало
20 Oct 25 at 8:39 am
можно купить диплом техникума [url=www.educ-ua7.ru]www.educ-ua7.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_wpea
20 Oct 25 at 8:41 am
кракен даркнет маркет
kraken 2025
JamesDaync
20 Oct 25 at 8:42 am
купить диплом биолога [url=rudik-diplom2.ru]купить диплом биолога[/url] .
Diplomi_btpi
20 Oct 25 at 8:42 am
Публикация предлагает уникальную подборку информации, которая будет интересна как специалистам, так и широкому кругу читателей. Здесь вы найдете ответы на часто задаваемые вопросы и полезные инсайты для дальнейшего применения.
Смотрите также… – https://www.controlv.cl/crea-tu-propio-cine-al-aire-libre-y-con-una-pantalla-de-hasta-100-pulgadas
BobbyDrift
20 Oct 25 at 8:45 am
где можно купить диплом техникум [url=http://frei-diplom8.ru/]где можно купить диплом техникум[/url] .
Diplomi_mjsr
20 Oct 25 at 8:45 am
диплом политехнического колледжа купить [url=www.frei-diplom11.ru]www.frei-diplom11.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_vssa
20 Oct 25 at 8:46 am
диплом проведенный купить [url=https://frei-diplom2.ru/]диплом проведенный купить[/url] .
Diplomi_rjEa
20 Oct 25 at 8:47 am
купить диплом с занесением в реестр москва [url=https://www.frei-diplom3.ru]купить диплом с занесением в реестр москва[/url] .
Diplomi_bgKt
20 Oct 25 at 8:47 am
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts
and I am waiting for your next post thank you once again.
시알리스 구매
20 Oct 25 at 8:48 am
Этот информационный материал собраны данные, которые помогут лучше понять текущие тенденции и процессы в различных сферах жизни. Мы предоставляем четкий анализ, графики и примеры, чтобы информация была не только понятной, но и практичной для принятия решений.
Слушай внимательно — тут важно – https://construction-chretienneau.fr/portfolio-view/villa-gassin/attachment/dcim100mediadji_0898-jpg
RalphDow
20 Oct 25 at 8:49 am
купить диплом в вольске [url=rudik-diplom8.ru]rudik-diplom8.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_mmMt
20 Oct 25 at 8:49 am
can i order generic tetracycline without rx
can i get cheap tetracycline online
20 Oct 25 at 8:52 am
обзор спортивных событий [url=https://sportivnye-novosti-2.ru/]обзор спортивных событий[/url] .
sportivnie novosti_zbma
20 Oct 25 at 8:52 am
как купить диплом с реестром [url=https://frei-diplom5.ru]как купить диплом с реестром[/url] .
Diplomi_umPa
20 Oct 25 at 8:55 am
купить вкладыш с оценками к диплому техникума [url=www.frei-diplom11.ru]купить вкладыш с оценками к диплому техникума[/url] .
Diplomi_zesa
20 Oct 25 at 8:55 am
купить диплом в ленинск-кузнецком [url=www.rudik-diplom2.ru]www.rudik-diplom2.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_mbpi
20 Oct 25 at 8:56 am
купить диплом колледжа [url=http://rudik-diplom8.ru]купить диплом колледжа[/url] .
Diplomi_jnMt
20 Oct 25 at 8:57 am
купить диплом электрика техникум [url=http://frei-diplom8.ru/]купить диплом электрика техникум[/url] .
Diplomi_sasr
20 Oct 25 at 8:57 am
I’ve been exploring for a little for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this sort of house
. Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site.
Studying this info So i’m glad to express that I’ve an incredibly good uncanny
feeling I discovered exactly what I needed.
I so much without a doubt will make sure to don?t forget this website and provides it a look on a
relentless basis.
nha cai mm99
20 Oct 25 at 8:58 am
купить диплом в симферополе [url=http://rudik-diplom14.ru]http://rudik-diplom14.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_xyea
20 Oct 25 at 9:02 am
Your style is unique compared to other people I’ve read stuff from.
Many thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this blog.
Adam & Eve toys
20 Oct 25 at 9:04 am
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky condemned Russian attacks on the Ukrainian regions of Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia and Sumy on Monday, saying that the Kremlin intends to “humiliate diplomatic efforts” just hours before European leaders visit the White House.
[url=https://kra42—at.ru]kra38 сс[/url]
“The Russian war machine continues to destroy lives despite everything,” Zelensky said in a statement, hours before he’s due to meet US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office. “That is precisely why we are seeking assistance to put an end to the killings. That is why reliable security guarantees are required. That is why Russia should not be rewarded for its participation in this war.”
[url=https://kra-42cc.com]kra40 сс[/url]
“Everyone seeks dignified peace and true security,” the Ukrainian president said. “And at this very moment, the Russians are attacking Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia, the Sumy region, and Odesa, destroying residential buildings and our civilian infrastructure.”
At least seven people were killed in Russia’s attack? on Kharkiv and a further three killed in the ballistic missile strike on the city of Zaporizhzhia, with scores more injured, according to Ukrainian authorities.
“This was a demonstrative and cynical Russian strike,” Zelensky added.
kra42 сс
https://kra-41–cc.ru
AndrewBlunk
20 Oct 25 at 9:04 am
The $MTAUR token presale milestones smash. Audits solid. Custom outfits stylish.
mtaur token
WilliamPargy
20 Oct 25 at 9:05 am
Этот информативный текст выделяется своими захватывающими аспектами, которые делают сложные темы доступными и понятными. Мы стремимся предложить читателям глубину знаний вместе с разнообразием интересных фактов. Откройте новые горизонты и развивайте свои способности познавать мир!
Смотрите также – https://www.authorlab.pro/shop/uncategorized/media-kit
Jamesfix
20 Oct 25 at 9:06 am
обзор спортивных событий [url=www.sportivnye-novosti-2.ru]обзор спортивных событий[/url] .
sportivnie novosti_vyma
20 Oct 25 at 9:06 am
Ich bin komplett hin und weg von SpinBetter Casino, es ist eine Erfahrung, die wie ein Wirbelsturm pulsiert. Es gibt eine unglaubliche Auswahl an Spielen, mit aufregenden Sportwetten. Die Agenten sind blitzschnell, garantiert top Hilfe. Die Gewinne kommen prompt, trotzdem die Offers konnten gro?zugiger ausfallen. Global gesehen, SpinBetter Casino ist ein Muss fur alle Gamer fur Adrenalin-Sucher ! Au?erdem die Interface ist intuitiv und modern, gibt den Anreiz, langer zu bleiben. Besonders toll die Vielfalt an Zahlungsmethoden, die den Spa? verlangern.
{{https://spinbettercasino.de/|spinbettercasino.de}|
SpinMasterZ7zef
20 Oct 25 at 9:08 am
купить диплом в сыктывкаре [url=https://rudik-diplom2.ru/]купить диплом в сыктывкаре[/url] .
Diplomi_ncpi
20 Oct 25 at 9:09 am
where buy tetracycline without prescription
can i order tetracycline without a prescription
20 Oct 25 at 9:09 am
купить диплом о высшем образовании с занесением в реестр в красноярске [url=www.frei-diplom3.ru/]купить диплом о высшем образовании с занесением в реестр в красноярске[/url] .
Diplomi_shKt
20 Oct 25 at 9:09 am
Adoro a erupcao de BetPrimeiro Casino, oferece uma aventura de cassino que borbulha como um geyser. A gama do cassino e simplesmente uma explosao de delicias, com caca-niqueis de cassino modernos e inflamados. O servico do cassino e confiavel e ardente, com uma ajuda que incendeia como uma tocha. Os saques no cassino sao velozes como uma corrente de lava, porem as ofertas do cassino podiam ser mais generosas. Em resumo, BetPrimeiro Casino e o point perfeito pros fas de cassino para os vulcanologos do cassino! De lambuja a plataforma do cassino brilha com um visual que e puro fogo, o que torna cada sessao de cassino ainda mais incendiaria.
casino online betprimeiro|
fizzylavacactus3zef
20 Oct 25 at 9:10 am
You are so interesting! I don’t believe I have read through a single thing like this before.
So nice to discover someone with some original thoughts on this issue.
Seriously.. thanks for starting this up. This site is something that’s needed on the
web, someone with a little originality!
mn88.com
20 Oct 25 at 9:10 am
Adoro o clima insano de DiceBet Casino, da uma energia de cassino que e fora da curva. O catalogo de jogos do cassino e uma loucura total, com slots de cassino unicos e empolgantes. O suporte do cassino ta sempre na ativa 24/7, dando solucoes claras na hora. As transacoes do cassino sao simples como um estalo, porem mais bonus regulares no cassino seria top. Em resumo, DiceBet Casino oferece uma experiencia de cassino que e puro gas para os cacadores de slots modernos de cassino! E mais a interface do cassino e fluida e cheia de estilo, torna o cassino uma curticao total.
dicebet Г© confiГЎvel|
zanycactus2zef
20 Oct 25 at 9:10 am
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky condemned Russian attacks on the Ukrainian regions of Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia and Sumy on Monday, saying that the Kremlin intends to “humiliate diplomatic efforts” just hours before European leaders visit the White House.
[url=https://kra-42-cc.com]kra42 at[/url]
“The Russian war machine continues to destroy lives despite everything,” Zelensky said in a statement, hours before he’s due to meet US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office. “That is precisely why we are seeking assistance to put an end to the killings. That is why reliable security guarantees are required. That is why Russia should not be rewarded for its participation in this war.”
[url=https://kra42-at.com]kra37[/url]
“Everyone seeks dignified peace and true security,” the Ukrainian president said. “And at this very moment, the Russians are attacking Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia, the Sumy region, and Odesa, destroying residential buildings and our civilian infrastructure.”
[url=https://kra42-cc.com]kra42 сс[/url]
At least seven people were killed in Russia’s attack? on Kharkiv and a further three killed in the ballistic missile strike on the city of Zaporizhzhia, with scores more injured, according to Ukrainian authorities.
[url=https://kra–41.cc]kra36[/url]
“This was a demonstrative and cynical Russian strike,” Zelensky added.
kra42 cc
https://kra42—cc.ru
HectorBoaps
20 Oct 25 at 9:12 am
купить диплом в елабуге [url=https://www.rudik-diplom10.ru]https://www.rudik-diplom10.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_ssSa
20 Oct 25 at 9:13 am
Ich finde absolut irre Lapalingo Casino, es fuhlt sich an wie ein wilder Ritt durch die Spielwelt. Der Katalog des Casinos ist ein Kaleidoskop des Spa?es, mit modernen Casino-Slots, die einen in ihren Bann ziehen. Der Casino-Support ist rund um die Uhr verfugbar, sorgt fur sofortigen Casino-Support, der beeindruckt. Der Casino-Prozess ist klar und ohne Wellen, ab und zu wurde ich mir mehr Casino-Promos wunschen, die explodieren. Kurz gesagt ist Lapalingo Casino ein Casino, das man nicht verpassen darf fur Fans moderner Casino-Slots! Und au?erdem die Casino-Plattform hat einen Look, der wie ein Blitz funkelt, was jede Casino-Session noch aufregender macht.
lapalingo sitz|
quirkyweasel2zef
20 Oct 25 at 9:14 am
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky condemned Russian attacks on the Ukrainian regions of Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia and Sumy on Monday, saying that the Kremlin intends to “humiliate diplomatic efforts” just hours before European leaders visit the White House.
[url=https://kra–41—cc.ru]kra40 cc[/url]
“The Russian war machine continues to destroy lives despite everything,” Zelensky said in a statement, hours before he’s due to meet US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office. “That is precisely why we are seeking assistance to put an end to the killings. That is why reliable security guarantees are required. That is why Russia should not be rewarded for its participation in this war.”
[url=https://kra-42-at.net]kra35 cc[/url]
“Everyone seeks dignified peace and true security,” the Ukrainian president said. “And at this very moment, the Russians are attacking Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia, the Sumy region, and Odesa, destroying residential buildings and our civilian infrastructure.”
At least seven people were killed in Russia’s attack? on Kharkiv and a further three killed in the ballistic missile strike on the city of Zaporizhzhia, with scores more injured, according to Ukrainian authorities.
“This was a demonstrative and cynical Russian strike,” Zelensky added.
kra36
https://kra–41.cc
Rafaelwem
20 Oct 25 at 9:14 am
Этот текст призван помочь читателю расширить кругозор и получить практические знания. Мы используем простой язык, наглядные примеры и структурированное изложение, чтобы сделать обучение максимально эффективным и увлекательным.
Всё, что нужно знать – https://nantsiplug.co.za/example-3/post-multi-page-slideshow/5
Michaellex
20 Oct 25 at 9:14 am
купить диплом в каменске-шахтинском [url=https://rudik-diplom3.ru]https://rudik-diplom3.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_dbei
20 Oct 25 at 9:15 am
купить диплом в магнитогорске [url=https://rudik-diplom14.ru]https://rudik-diplom14.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_woea
20 Oct 25 at 9:16 am
как купить диплом занесенный в реестр [url=frei-diplom6.ru]как купить диплом занесенный в реестр[/url] .
Diplomi_euOl
20 Oct 25 at 9:16 am
диплом техникума купить [url=https://frei-diplom8.ru/]диплом техникума купить[/url] .
Diplomi_qnsr
20 Oct 25 at 9:16 am
купить диплом с регистрацией [url=www.frei-diplom2.ru/]купить диплом с регистрацией[/url] .
Diplomi_pnEa
20 Oct 25 at 9:17 am
купить диплом с проводкой кого [url=https://www.frei-diplom3.ru]купить диплом с проводкой кого[/url] .
Diplomi_zdKt
20 Oct 25 at 9:18 am
What i do not realize is actually how you’re no longer actually much more neatly-liked than you might be now.
You are very intelligent. You know thus considerably in relation to this matter, produced me personally believe it from a lot of numerous angles.
Its like men and women are not involved except it’s one thing to accomplish with Girl gaga!
Your own stuffs great. All the time take care of it up!
dewascatter
20 Oct 25 at 9:18 am
диплом колледжа купить в москве [url=https://www.frei-diplom9.ru]https://www.frei-diplom9.ru[/url] .
Diplomi_tlea
20 Oct 25 at 9:20 am
1хбет действующий промокод на сегодня. Пользователи при регистрации или позже могут воспользоваться промокодами для получения различных бонусов от букмекерской конторы. Найти эти коды можно на различных тематических сайтах, а также на рабочем зеркале. 1xBet предлагает несколько способов регистрации на рабочем зеркале сайта. Компания внимательно относится к новым клиентам, поэтому предполагает многоуровневую систему защиты от того, чтобы дети не смогли заключать пари. согласно международному праву, наказание за это нарушение – штраф и отзыв лицензии. Регистрация в 1 клик. Так называется ускоренный процесс создания учетной записи. Актуальные промокоды на 1xBet бесплатно можно получить: На нашем портале. На сайтах интернет-ресурсов партнёров букмекерской конторы или различных СМИ. Любой желающий может достаточно просто найти промокод 1xBet на сегодня бесплатно. Бонусы – достойные, а условия их получения – реальные и осуществимые. А в некоторых случаях вообще ничего делать не надо.
Stanleyvonna
20 Oct 25 at 9:21 am